ÅëÇÕ°Ë»ö
¾ÆÀ̵𠠠 ºñ¹Ð¹øÈ£
   ÀÚµ¿·Î±×ÀÎ     
  ÇöÀç ÃÑ 131¸í Á¢¼ÓÁßÀÔ´Ï´Ù. (ȸ¿ø 0 ¸í / ¼Õ´Ô 131 ¸í)     ÃֽŰԽñ۠   ¼º°æ°Ë»ö   
È­ÀÌÆ®Çìµå
öÇÐ
»çȸ°úÇÐ
ÀÚ¿¬°úÇÐ
ÄË Àª¹ö(Ken Wilber)
ºÒ±³¿Í ½É¸®ÇÐ
Çмú¹ø¿ª


  ¹æ¹®°´ Á¢¼ÓÇöȲ
¿À´Ã 468
¾îÁ¦ 685
ÃÖ´ë 10,145
Àüü 3,479,005



    Á¦ ¸ñ : [Æß] ¾ÆÄû³ª½º, ÇÏÀ̵¥°Å, È­ÀÌÆ®Çìµå    
  ±Û¾´ÀÌ : Á¤°­±æ ³¯ Â¥ : 06-10-08 21:14 Á¶È¸(9140)
   Æ®·¢¹é ÁÖ¼Ò : http://freeview.org/bbs/tb.php/e001/5 


¾Æ·¡ÀÇ ±ÛÀº ÆÛ¿Â ±ÛÀÓ´Ù..
..........................................................
 
[2001-11-12 09:19:53]
 
 
.. ´ÙÀ½Àº D.R. GriffinÀÇ ¾ÆÄû³ª½º¿Í ÇÏÀ̵¥°Å¿Í È­ÀÌÆ®Çìµå¿¡ °üÇÑ ÂªÀº
ºñ±³ÀÔ´Ï´Ù. Á¦°¡ ´Ù ¼ÒÈ­½ÃÅ°Áö ¸ø ÇÑ ±ÛÀ» ¿Å±ä´Â°Ô ¸¶À½¿¡ °É¸®Áö¸¸,
Ȥ½Ã µµ¿òÀÌ µÉ±îÇؼ­ ¿Ã¸³´Ï´Ù.
 
 
"Thomas Aquinas, although he was anticipated by others, was the theologian who most throughly identified God with being. Presupposing Aristotle's analysis of matter and form, he saw that neither of them nor their combination could account for the very being of things. What is required, he argued is an act of being, Which he called being itself, esse ipsum. Thomas identified this act of being with God, defined as that Being whose very essence it is to exis. Contingent beings exist by virtue of their participation in being itself, which means that God is the necessary ground of their being. For Thomas, then, God is not only a concrete being, the God of the Bible, but also being itself.
 

it is this equation that Whitehead's position rejects. One basis for Whitehead's different view is that he no longer needed to affirm an act of being different from the matterial cause of all things. Whereas Thomas followed Aristotle in regarding matter as passive, developments in modern physics have led to the idea that which all things embody is dynamic activity, better describable as energy than as matter. Enlarging this notions to creativity, Whitehead had a concept that not only filled the role played by the Thomistic act of being but also could replace, rather than merely supplement, the Aristotelian matter. Then, given the idea that this creativity itself - this being itself, this act of being - is simply the stuff of which all actual beings exist, it was obvious that it could not a being, so that it could not intelligibly be called God.
 

Parallel with this rejection of the identification of being itself with a supreme being on the part of Whitehead and his followers has been an even more explicit rejection of it by Martin Heidegger and his followers. The "onto-theological" metaphysical tradition, Heidegger argued, had blurred the all-important "ontological difference" between being(Sein) and beings (Seinde) - which is exactly parallel with Whitehead's distinction between creativity and actual entities. Once this ontological difference is seen, Heidegger insisted, the equation of being itself (esse ipsum) with any being, even a necessary being (esse ipsum subsistens), is unintelligible. "
 
 
D.R. Griffin, Reenchantment without Supernaturalism, Ithaca and London: Cornell University press, 2001. pp.269-270. 
 
 2001-11-12 09:19:53


°Ô½Ã¹°¼ö 74°Ç / ÄÚ¸àÆ®¼ö 40°Ç RSS
 
¹øÈ£ Á¦¸ñ ±Û¾´ÀÌ Á¶È¸ ³¯Â¥
öÇÐÀÇ ±âÃÊ°¡ ¾ø´Â ºÐµé²² ±ÇÇÏ´Â ÁÁÀº µ¿¿µ»ó ÀÚ·á (*Àç¹Õ½À´Ï´Ù^.^) (2) °ü¸®ÀÚ 26237 07-16
öÇÐÀ» °øºÎÇÏ´Â ÀÌÀ¯ (1) Á¤°­±æ 18125 04-23
74 [¸ÍÀÚ] õÇÏ¿¡ µµÔ³°¡ ¾ø´Â °Íµµ ÇÏ´ÃÀÇ ¶æÀΰ¡? ¹Ì¼± 766 03-22
73 ¿ì¸®ÀÇ Áö½Ä ±³À°ÀÌ ÆÄÆíÀû, ³ª¿­Àû, ÀýÃæÀûÀ̱⠽¬¿î ÀÌÀ¯ ¹Ì¼± 2416 04-22
72 Å»·¹½º, öÇÐÀÇ ÃâÇö°ú ±× ÀÇ¹Ì ¹Ì¼± 2227 10-01
71 ²Þ²Û ¾ê±â, öÇÐÀº <³»°¡ ¼ÓÇÑ º¸ÀÌÁö ¾Ê´Â Àüü Áý>À» ÆľÇÇÏ´Â °Í ¹Ì¼± 2764 11-05
70 ¡®¸ÞÀ̵å ÀÎ ÄÚ¸®¾Æ¡¯ öÇÐÀ» °³Ã´ÇÑ ¹ÌÁöÀÇ Ã¶ÇÐÀÚ(½Åµ¿¾Æ) (2) ¹Ì¼± 4053 06-03
69 ¾ËÆ¢¼¼ÀÇ 'È£¸í'¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ºñÆÇÀû µ¶ÇØ (ÁøÅ¿ø) ¹Ì¼± 36781 05-07
68 Å«³¡Àº ³¡ÀÌ ¾ø´Ù_¹«±ØÀÌűØ(Ùíпì»÷¼Ð¿) (Á¶¿ëÇö) (1) ¹Ì¼± 5012 05-03
67 ¸öÀÇ MÃþÀ» Çü¼ºÇÏ´Â ÇüÀÌ»óÇÐ.. ±× ÁøÈ­Àû ±â¿ø, ¹Ì¼± 3087 03-11
66 Çѳª ¾Æ·»Æ®°¡ ¸»ÇÏ´Â <¾ÇÀÇ Æò¹ü¼º> ¹Ì¼± 4662 02-23
65 ¼­±¸ ±Ù´ë¸¦ Áö¹èÇß´ø <µ¥Ä«¸£Æ®-´ºÅÏ ¼¼°è°ü>À̶õ? ¹Ì¼± 3983 02-21
64 Á¾±³, öÇÐ, °úÇÐÀ̶ó´Â 3°¡Áö ÀüÅëÀÇ ¼ÒÅë °ü°è ¹Ì¼± 3944 01-17
63 ÅëºÐ¼®Àû »ç°í ¹Ì¼± 4613 10-11
62 ºÒ±³¿¡ ´ëÇÑ È­ÀÌÆ®ÇìµåÀÇ »ý°¢ ¹Ì¼± 3818 09-16
61 °æÇèÀÇ µÎ Ãø¸é : <ÃøÁ¤°¡´ÉÀÇ °æÇè>°ú <ÃøÁ¤ºÒ´ÉÀÇ °æÇè> ¹Ì¼± 3820 04-27
60 "Á¸Àç(being)À» Èû(power)"À¸·Î Á¤ÀÇÇÑ ÇöóÅæ ÀúÀÛÀÇ Èñ¶ø ¿ø¹®°ú ¿µ¿ª ¹Ì¼± 4715 05-24
59 Àι®ÇÐÀÚ´Â °úÇÐÀÌ ¹«¼·´Ù? ÁøÂ¥ 'À¶ÇÕ' °¡´ÉÇÏ·Á¸é¡¦(ÃÖÁ¾´ö) (4) ¹Ì¼± 6849 01-12
58 ÆíÇâ ÁßÀÇ ÆíÇâ, <ÇüÀÌ»óÇÐÀû ÆíÇâ> ¹Ì¼± 8758 07-28
57 ±èÀçÀÎ ¿¬±¸¿ø, ÁöÁ§ÀÇ µé·ÚÁî µ¶ÇØ ºñÆÇ (1) ¹Ì¼± 7450 07-10
56 ÇüÀÌ»óÇÐÀÇ ¿ªÇÒÀ» ¹«½ÃÇÏ´Â ºÐµé¿¡°Ô.. (6) ¹Ì¼± 8899 09-03
55 Àι®ÇÐÀº °úÇп¡ ÀÚ¸®¸¦ ³»ÁÖ¾î¾ß Çϴ°¡ (ÀÌ»óÇå) (1) ¹Ì¼± 7784 08-16
54 ÁöÁ§ÀÌ ¸¸³­ ·¹´Ñ (Á¶¹èÁØ) (1) ¹Ì¼± 7420 07-18
53 ½½¶óº¸¿¹ ÁöÁ§ ÀÎÅͺä Àü¹® / Çѱ¹ÀϺ¸ (2) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 9157 02-11
52 °øÀÚ¿Í ¿¹¼ö, µµ¿Ã ÁÖÀå¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ¹Ý·Ð ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 8059 12-06
51 öÇÐÀÇ ±âÃÊ°¡ ¾ø´Â ºÐµé²² ±ÇÇÏ´Â ÁÁÀº µ¿¿µ»ó ÀÚ·á (*Àç¹Õ½À´Ï´Ù^.^) (2) °ü¸®ÀÚ 26237 07-16
50 ±¹³»¿Ü öÇлó´ã °ü·Ã ¹®Çå (Ãâó: öÇлó´ãÄ¡·áÇÐȸ) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 7939 06-07
49 Çѱ¹°¶·´ ÃÖÃÊ Çѱ¹ÀΠöÇÐ ÀÎ½Ä Á¶»ç (1) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 9071 01-31
48 [Æß] µ¿¾çöÇлç»ó À½¾ç¿ÀÇ༳ ºñÆÇ ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 18995 12-17
47 öÇÐÀ» »ýÀü óÀ½À¸·Î °øºÎÇÏ´Â ÁøÂ¥ ÃʽÉÀںеéÀ» À§ÇÑ ¾È³» Ã¥µé ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 8302 11-06
46 »î°ú Çй®Àû Ž±¸¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ³ªÀÇ »ý°¢..(Àª¹ö ºñÆǵµ ¾à°£..) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 9867 09-30
45 ¿¹¼ú¿¡ ´ëÇÑ °¨»ó°ú À¯Èñ ±×¸®°í Áø¸® ´ã·Ð°ú ¹ÌÀû °¡Ä¡ ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 9553 09-19
44 ±×°ÍÀº ³ªÀÇ <ÁÖ°üÀû ´À³¦>Àϱî? ÂüµÈ <°´°üÀû ÀÌÇØ>Àϱî? ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 8703 09-03
43 °úÇÐÃ¥¡º¿ìÁÖÀÇ ±¸Á¶¡»¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ¾î´À öÇÐÀÚÀÇ ¼­Æò (2) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 10566 03-13
42 öÇÐ ¼ºÇâ Å×½ºÆ® (±×¸°ºñ) (6) Á¤°­±æ 11023 03-02
41 öÇÐÀÌ ÇÊ¿äÇÑ ÀÌÀ¯ Çϳª Á¤°­±æ 12328 11-20
40 [Æß] ¾ÈÅä´Ï¿À ³×±×¸® (Antonio Negri, 1933~) °í°ñÅ×½º 10614 05-25
39 [Æß] ÆäÅÍ ½½·ÎÅÍ´ÙÀÌÅ© (Peter Sloterdijk, 1947~) °í°ñÅ×½º 10981 05-25
38 [Æß] ¿ä°¡Ã¶ÇÐ Á¤°­±æ 10359 04-24
37 '¾Ë·© ¹Ùµð¿ì'¿¡ ´ëÇÏ¿© ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 13088 03-07
36 ¾Ë·© ¹Ùµð¿ì-Áø¸®¿Í ÁÖüÀÇ Ã¶ÇÐ (¼­¿ë¼ø) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 19426 03-07
35 °¡´Ù¸ÓÀÇ ¡¸Áø¸®¿Í ¹æ¹ý¡¹ (2) ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 16340 10-14
34 È£¸ð ¸ð¹Ì¿£½º (±è¿ë¿Á) Á¤°­±æ 11605 03-28
33 ÁÖü ÇØüÀÇ ½Ã´ë¿¡ ÁÖü ¸»Çϱâ (2) »ê¼öÀ¯ 10466 12-05
32 '¾Æ´Ô/ºñ¿ò/¹Ý´ë/¹ö¸²/²÷À½/¾øÀ½' °°Àº ºÎÁ¤¹ý Ç¥ÇöÀÌ °®´Â ÇÑ°è ¹Ì¼±ÀÌ 9658 06-07
31 öÇаú ½ÅÇÐÀÇ °ü°è2 (*±ÇÇÏ´Â ±Û) Á¤°­±æ 12593 05-07
30 öÇаú ½ÅÇÐÀÇ °ü°è1 (*±ÇÇÏ´Â ±Û) Á¤°­±æ 12990 05-06
29 ¾ð¾î¿Í ¿ìÁÖ ±×¸®°í öÇÐ Á¤°­±æ 9872 04-21
28 "ÁÁ´Ù/½È´Ù"¿Í "¿Ç´Ù/Ʋ·È´Ù"ÀÇ Ç¥Çöµé, ¾î¶»°Ô º¼ °ÍÀΰ¡ : °¨¼º°ú À̼ºÀÇ ¹®Á¦ Á¤°­±æ 11310 04-13
27 ¸¶¸£Æ¾ ÇÏÀ̵¥°ÅÀÇ »ý¾Ö¿Í »ç»ó À̱â»ó 29149 11-12
26 ³í¸®¿Í Á÷°ü, ±×¸®°í °¨°¢¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ³íÀǵé (´äº¯: Á¤°­±æ) ÀÌÀç¿ì 11669 11-11
25 ½É¸®ÇÐ ¹× Á¤½ÅºÐ¼® ±×¸®°í öÇÐ(Á¸Àç·Ð) Á¤°­±æ 11788 11-11
24 [Æß] À±È¸, »ç½ÇÀΰ¡ »ç»óÀΰ¡ Á¤°­±æ 14182 11-11
23 [To. µé·ÚÁö¾È ±èÀçÀÎ] µÎ °¡Áö Áú¹®.. Á¤°­±æ 10396 11-11
22 [To. µé·ÚÁî¾È ±èÀçÀÎ] ºÎÁ¤¼ºÀ» °£Á÷ÇÑ Å»ÁÖfuite ¹ø¿ªÀº ¾î¶³Áö¿ä.. Á¤°­±æ 13141 11-11
21 [ÀÚ·á]¡ºÃµ °³ÀÇ °í¿ø¡»ÀÌ ¡º³ë¸¶µðÁò¡»¿¡°Ô (±èÀçÀÎ) Á¤°­±æ 12388 11-11
20 ³×±×¸®, À¯¹°·Ð°ú ºñÀ¯¹°·ÐÀÇ °æ°è¼±¿¡¼­ Á¤°­±æ 9245 11-11
19 ¡´Å»Áß½ÉÁÖÀÇ¡µÈ¤Àº¡´ÇØüÁÖÀÇ¡µÀÇ ÇÑ°è Á¤°­±æ 10660 11-11
18 [Æß] ¸¼½º, À¯¹°·Ð, Á¸Àç·ÐÀû ÇüÀÌ»óÇÐ Á¤°­±æ 11315 11-11
17 [Æß] ¿Ö ¡¶¿Ö µ¿¾çöÇÐÀΰ¡?¡·Àΰ¡ À嵿¿ì 10638 11-11
16 ¹«Á¤Ã¼¼º/´ÙÁ¤Ã¼¼º ȤÀº »ó´ëÁÖÀǸ¦ ÁÖÀåÇÏ´Â »ç¶÷µé¿¡°Ô ´øÁö´Â ¿ìÈ­ Á¤°­±æ 10449 11-10
15 ´Ù¾ç¼ºÀÇ »ý»ê°ú ´Ù¾ç¼º °£ÀÇ Ãæµ¹¿¡ ´ëÇÑ °íÂû Á¤°­±æ 10378 07-10
14 ½½¶óº¸ÀÌ ÁöÁ§Slavoj Zizek Á¤½ÅºÐ¼®ÇÐÀû »çȸÀÌ·Ð ¾ç¿î´ö 10971 10-08
13 [Æß] "Æ÷½ºÆ®¸ð´õ´ÏÁò" ¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ÃνºÅ°ÀÇ °ßÇØ Á¤°­±æ 14376 10-08
12 µé·ÚÁî¿Í °¡Å¸¸®ÀÇ ±â°è °³³ä (¼­µ¿¿í) Á¤°­±æ 20483 10-08
11 [Ã¥] ¡º¶ó±øÀÇ Àçź»ý¡» ±è»óȯ¤ýÈ«Áر⠿«À½ °ü¸®ÀÚ 11723 10-08
10 ÀÚ¿¬°ú ½Å°ú Àΰ£, ±×¸®°í ±Ù´ë Çй®ÀÇ Åº»ý ÀÌÇöÈÖ 9773 10-08
9 [20¼¼±â »ç»óÀ» ã¾Æ¼­] Áú µé·ÚÁîÀÇ Ã¶ÇÐ Á¤°­±æ 13994 10-08
8 [Æß] ¸ð´õ´ÏÁò Á¤°­±æ 12431 10-08
7 [Æß] ŸÀÚÀÇ ÇöÇö, À±¸®ÀÇ ÁöÆò(·¹ºñ³ª½º »ç»ó ¼Ò°³¼­) (3) Á¤°­±æ 13131 10-08
6 ·¹ºñ³ª½º »ç»ó¿¡ ´ëÇÑ ÁÁÀº °³·Ð¼­ Á¤°­±æ 10476 10-08
5 [Æß] ·¹ºñ³ª½º¸¦ ¾Æ½Ã³ª¿ä? (1) Á¤°­±æ 12876 10-08
4 [Âü°íÀÚ·á]º»Àΰú ÀÌÁ¤¿ì(µé·ÚÁî¾È)¿ÍÀÇ ³íÀï ±Û¸ðÀ½ Á¤°­±æ 16245 10-08
3 [Æß] ¾ÆÄû³ª½º, ÇÏÀ̵¥°Å, È­ÀÌÆ®Çìµå Á¤°­±æ 9141 10-08
2 <À߸ø ³õ¿©Áø ±¸Ã¼¼ºÀÇ ¿À·ù>¿¡ ºüÁø µé·ÚÁî (2) Á¤°­±æ 19498 05-01
1 öÇÐÀ» °øºÎÇÏ´Â ÀÌÀ¯ (1) Á¤°­±æ 18125 04-23



Institute for Transformation of World and Christianity